(.. 2 ..)
QUESTION BANK
Q.1. Write a full-dressed note on the preamble of the Constitution.
Q.2. Explain the nature and Scope of the preamble to the Constitution of India.
Q.3. Explain the significance of ‘Preamble’ in the Indian Constitution and discuss whether it forms a part of the Constitution or not
Q.4. Discuss the role of the preamble in the interpretation of the Constitutional provisions.
Q.5. Can the Preamble be amended under Art. 368, of the Constitution? Answer with reference to the decided cases.
SYNOPSIS
i. The Early View (In Re: Berubari Union, 1960):
ii. The Modern Settled View (Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala, 1973):
*****
Every modern written constitution or major statute typically begins with a Preamble. The Preamble serves as an introductory statement that outlines the primary objectives, the underlying philosophy, the core policy choices, and the legislative intent of the framers. It sets the tone for the entire legal document.
In the landmark case In Re: Berubari Union [AIR 1960 SC 845], the Supreme Court of India beautifully illuminated this concept by stating:
"The Preamble is the key to open the minds of the Constitution-makers. It shows the general purpose for which they made the several provisions of the Constitution."
The formal text of the Preamble reads as follows:
"WE, THE PEOPLE OF INDIA, having solemnly resolved to constitute India into a SOVEREIGN, SOCIALIST, SECULAR, DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC and to secure to all its citizens:
JUSTICE, social, economic and political;
LIBERTY of thought, expression, belief, faith and worship;
EQUALITY of status and of opportunity; and to promote among them all
FRATERNITY assuring the dignity of the individual and the unity and integrity of the Nation;
IN OUR CONSTITUENT ASSEMBLY this twenty-sixth day of November, 1949, do HEREBY ADOPT, ENACT AND GIVE TO OURSELVES THIS CONSTITUTION."
The Preamble can be broken down into four essential components: the source of constitutional authority, the nature of the Indian State, the objectives of the legal system, and the date of adoption.
1. Popular Sovereignty:
This opening phrase indicates the ultimate source of power and legitimacy from which the Constitution derives its authority. It proclaims that sovereignty resides in the people of India rather than any external or internal monarchical power.
2. The Social Contract:
It reflects a democratic "social contract" where the citizens have mutually agreed among themselves to form a governed society.
3. Self-Enacted:
The concluding line, "do hereby adopt, enact and give to ourselves this Constitution," emphasizes that the text was created by an indigenous Constituent Assembly representing the population, and was not mandated or imposed by any foreign ruler or external empire.
The Preamble characterizes the foundational nature of the Indian political framework using five core descriptors: hr Democratic & Republic
The term denotes absolute independence. India is entirely free from external control or coercion by foreign powers (such as the British Crown) and is supreme within its own domestic territorial boundaries. It has the unfettered legal capacity to acquire foreign territory or cede its own in accordance with international law.
i. Amended Status: This term was explicitly inserted into the Preamble via the 42nd Constitutional Amendment Act of 1976.
ii. Core Meaning: Broadly speaking, socialism implies state ownership or regulation of the principal means of production and distribution.
iii. The Indian Context: India does not practice rigid state-controlled "communistic socialism." Instead, it practices Democratic Socialism, which envisions a mixed economy where both the private sector and public sector co-exist side-by-side to eliminate poverty, ignorance, disease, and inequality of opportunity.
i. Amended Status: This term was also introduced via the 42nd Constitutional Amendment Act of 1976.
ii. Core Meaning: It declares that the State has no official, recognized religion of its own.
iii. Contemporary Distinction: Unlike traditional theocratic states (such as Pakistan, which is constitutionally declared an Islamic Republic), India treats all religions with equal respect, protection, and neutrality (Sarva Dharma Sambhava). The State neither sponsors nor discriminates against any religious faith.
This signifies a system of governance that derives its legitimate power directly from the collective will of the people. The operational framework relies on Universal Adult Suffrage, regular competitive elections, the rule of law, and the independence of the judiciary.
A republic indicates that the executive head of state is elected, rather than inheriting power through a hereditary monarchy.
In India, the President serves as the Head of State. While the President is not elected directly by the populace (unlike the President of the United States), they are elected indirectly through an electoral college consisting of the people's directly elected representatives (Members of Parliament and Members of Legislative Assemblies).
The Preamble outlines four core objectives that the State is mandated to secure for its citizenry:
i. Social Justice: Demands the absolute elimination of systemic social inequalities rooted in prejudice regarding race, religion, caste, sex, or wealth. It seeks to uplift marginalized sections and abolish historical institutional biases like untouchability.
ii. Economic Justice: Mandates that economic disparities should not result in the exploitation of individuals. It aims for equitable wealth distribution, ensuring concepts like "equal pay for equal work" regardless of gender or social status.
iii. Political Justice: Ensures all citizens possess equal opportunities to participate in political processes without arbitrary or unreasonable barriers. Every individual possesses an equal vote under the law.
True human development requires mental and spiritual liberty. The Constitution secures these essential rights through the enforceable provisions of Part III (Fundamental Rights), such as Article 19 (Freedom of Speech) and Articles 25–28 (Freedom of Religion). These safeguards ensure individuals can think, communicate, and practice their chosen faith without unwarranted state surveillance or interference.
The Preamble seeks to provide a level playing field for every citizen by removing systemic privileges or biases. This is codified within Articles 14 to 18 of the Constitution, which abolish state-sponsored discrimination, throw open public places to all individuals, eliminate aristocratic titles, and guarantee equal access to public sector employment and state offices.
Fraternity emphasizes a deep spirit of common brotherhood, reinforcing the understanding that all citizens are children of the same shared motherland.
While the main text of the Constitution does not feature a single, standalone clause labeled "Fraternity" , this objective is woven into its structural layout through mechanisms like Single Citizenship (ensuring national identity over regional bias) and the freedom to move, reside, and settle anywhere across India.
Additionally, the Fundamental Duties (Article 51-A) explicitly task every citizen with promoting harmony and the spirit of common brotherhood among all people.
The legal status of the Preamble and its relationship with Article 368 have evolved through landmark judicial rulings:. • Can be amended, subject to "Basic Structure".
i. The Early View (In Re: Berubari Union, 1960): The Supreme Court initially held that while the Preamble serves as an invaluable guide to interpreting the intent of the framers, it is not structurally a part of the Constitution. Consequently, it was viewed as non-enforceable and incapable of restricting or expanding the clear wording of specific articles.
ii. The Modern Settled View (Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala [AIR 1973 SC 1461], 1973): A larger bench of the Supreme Court explicitly overruled the Berubari position. The Court observed that the Preamble went through the exact same legislative process of voting and adoption in the Constituent Assembly as the rest of the Articles. Therefore, the Supreme Court ruled that the Preamble is an integral part of the Constitution.
The Preamble acts as an interpretative roadmap for the judiciary.
If the language of any constitutional provision or statutory act is found to be ambiguous, vague, or capable of multiple interpretations, judges look to the Preamble to clarify the core policy objectives and intent of the framers.
However, the Preamble itself cannot overrule an explicit, completely unambiguous provision of the Constitution, nor is it a direct source of enforceable power or prohibition for the legislature.
This definitive question was answered in the historic Kesavananda Bharati case (1973):
The Supreme Court held that since the Preamble is part of the Constitution, Parliament possesses the authority to amend it under Article 368, just like any other constitutional provision.
However, this amending power is restricted by the Doctrine of Basic Structure. Parliament cannot use Article 368 to alter, damage, or destroy the fundamental features enshrined within the Preamble (such as Democracy, Secularism, Republican character, and Sovereign status).
To date, the Preamble has been amended only once in the history of independent India: via the 42nd Constitutional Amendment Act of 1976. This single amendment added three specific words to the text: "Socialist", "Secular", and "Integrity". The judiciary subsequently upheld this amendment as valid, noting that it reinforced and expanded the existing foundational principles of the nation without undermining its basic structure.
*****